So one of the neighbor guys (completely unrelated to any of the women I met) came over and invited Tom to a beer night!
While he was gone he texted me this:

And then didn’t answer…for like five minutes! So I was all freaking out. Then he finally continued…

It turns out all the guys (couples) had been friends of the past owners!
That was all I heard from him until he walked in around 11:30. He didn’t say much—which made me a little crazy because I wanted to know all about them. I found out in the morning that he was a little more drunk than he thought so he just went straight to bed. Haha.